We present deepflash2, a deep learning solution that facilitates the objective and reliable segmentation of ambiguous bioimages through multi-expert annotations and integrated quality assurance. Thereby, deepflash2 addresses typical challenges that arise during training, evaluation, and application of deep learning models in bioimaging. The tool is embedded in an easy-to-use graphical user interface and offers best-in-class predictive performance for semantic and instance segmentation under economical usage of computational resources.