Modern databases and data-warehousing systems separate query processing and durable storage. Storage systems have idiosyncratic bugs and security vulnerabilities, thus attacks that compromise only storage are a realistic threat. In this paper, we show that encryption alone is not sufficient to protect databases from compromised storage. Using MongoDB WiredTiger as a concrete example, we demonstrate that sizes of encrypted writes to a durable write-ahead log can reveal sensitive information about the inputs and activities of MongoDB applications. We then design, implement, and evaluate BigFoot, a WAL modification that mitigates size leakage.